Readers Write In #585: Book Review: Plassey- The Battle that Changed the Course of Indian History

by bollywoodbubbles
0 comment 84 views

By Vishnu Mahesh Sharma

Who would have imagined that the emperor’s crotch doctor’s treatment would lay the foundation for one of the decisive battles in Indian history? Who would have thought that a helpless nymphomaniac widow would cast a dooming spell on one of India’s richest states? Who would have imagined with trout Fight? A slap in the face of a banker in court would haunt you in the form of cannons and grape shots to bring poetic justice to the spoiled brat and warmonger prince. who would have imagined Who would have imagined this battle decades away? plushie Will it serve as the template and precursor to Britain’s most economical victory on the subcontinent? Kite sellers and Persian tutors will listen to the earth and write the fate of war before it even begins. who would have imagined And most importantly, who would have imagined that a game-changing battle for European supremacy in India would not be a matter of war? nawab Regarding the company, I will explain in detail about the UK vs. France. sabha and Sabhadar Was there collateral damage in Bengal?

There are two ways to search for answers. First, when due diligence is carried out, a large number of archives, documents and books are read, researched, factually supported, documented in a document-like approach freed of unwarranted imagination, and in logical and historical order. be edited. Second, although all due diligence has been done, compilation has been replaced by interpretation, documentary approaches have been replaced by narrative methods, and literary richness and prosperity has been replaced by tonality. preferred over formal, dry approaches. The latter is undoubtedly a more engaging and entertaining read, while the former is more scholarly and textually rich as formal history.

So, considering the scope of the above questionnaire, if you’re looking for the thrill and glitz of a story,plushie To sudeep chakravarti‘ is not his/her cup of tea. Because here the author shows a great deal of restraint in not yielding to his imagination and interpretation. For a book based on historical events with so many colorful and gray characters, this is a great achievement. chakravarti You can keep a discreet yet interesting tone.

Wherever creative freedom is allowed, Sudeep It cleverly refers to a work that has already taken away its liberty in its context. He provides verbatim snippets of that work and its practice. He is known as the most honest formal historian. However, in places, the formal approach of taking no sides can also work as a downside for this otherwise very good book. The most obvious loophole in this regard is his explanation. Siraj Wood Doula. In this work he quotes how books A, B, and C show. Shiraji Portrayed as a hopeless alcoholic, a lustful bisexual playgirl, and a greedy property thief as a price for cruelty, in books X, Y, and Z, he is betrayed by his best friend. It depicts how he was portrayed as a person who was a man and stood up for him. Subship, determined to exclude the English from the eastern states of the subcontinent.butSudeep We readers are never taught or guided as to how to read. Siraj character or manner Sudeep myself watching Shiraji.

Conversely, if the numbers are: gassetti like Begum Murshid Kuri Khan or something Aribaldi Khan, we get a glimpse of his reading on these plushie letter. In his defense, however, it can be argued that the book is not a biographical work. Shirajibut documents the events before and after. plushie war.

In that respect, this work is a reading gem. The author starts from the time of the Mughal Empire and emphasizes the relationship (and its background) between Delhi and Bengal Suva, Bengal Suva and John Company, John Company and France Company, and France Company and France Company. By doing so, he succeeded in establishing the geopolitics of the time.Bengal Suva and surrounds plushie Year.Optionally, the writer can Sudeep By giving socio-religious commentary and foreshadowing, he abandons the historian in him (I could have followed the route of the author telling the story, but it is a formality. There are some examples where the style repeats the choice of .)

The formal approach is also evident in the subheadings of each chapter, which are quotations from other official letters and documents. However, with this kind of approach, the book becomes complicated in establishing links between different individuals, organizations and places, ranging from British, French, Dutch, Armenian and corporate. may have been Sepoy for three generations nawab against wicked women, against loyal (disloyal) and influential bankers (Seth) There are deceitful commanders, military strategists, spies, eunuchs, mango fields, rivers and whatever. But talking about players and their backstories all at once, chakravarti Connect all these dots carefully and set the stage for battle with great success.

The book seamlessly blends the geography of the time with the political economy of the time. Therefore, light comments and anecdotes about local flavors such as food, language and lifestyle are passed on whenever there is an opportunity. That one of the motives for war can be traced back to the keeping of personal and organizational financial records is pure genius and a work of observation.

Credit should also be given to the author for portraying Robert Clive in a way that seems neither an insurmountable God-sent gifted commander nor an outright greed-driven villain. Here he remained an insecure and vulnerable colonel, making some blunders and some brilliant war decisions, using both combat and bribery as a means to win a favorable position.

While many events are intertwined, Sudeep He could have easily taken the opportunity to show off his knowledge and talents by derailing into the famous and captivating rivalry of Clive and Duplex. But he is merely alluding to it and never goes out of his way to keep the focus on Bengal and its inhabitants (non-residents).

the historian of chakravarti The company does not hesitate to provide a small chronicle of the lives of the co-conspirators who we believed were minor players but who ultimately profited the most from the revolution. These two characters are Kant Bab and raja nava krishna. As a matter of course, Sudeep Dedicate a few ink cartridges to their life story.

By the end, when the fates and afterlife of each major/minor player, conspirator, and warrior are explained in a mix of hearsay and travel blogging hues, who would have thought of reading ostensibly like a treatise? I thought about it. Will your readership grow slowly, eventually replenishing your artillery and muskets with your understanding of such historical events? A book for curious minds who are patient enough to read as A story based on the past. There’s nothing wrong with the second approach, just that this book works better than the former or the first.

You may also like

Leave a Comment